top of page

The “Diabetes Diet” Isn’t Actually That Special

Writer: Shavonne Wood, RD
Shavonne Wood, RD
Oct 29
5 min read

November is Diabetes Awareness Month, and as a Registered Dietitian and Certified Diabetes Educator, there’s one message I wish more people understood about eating with diabetes: A “diabetes diet” really isn’t that special or different.


There is no separate aisle of foods you suddenly need to shop from after a diabetes diagnosis. You don’t necessarily need any special “diabetic” foods, you don’t need to eliminate carbohydrates, and you certainly don’t need to resign yourself to a lifetime without bread, pasta, potatoes or dessert.


In fact, when I talk to someone who has recently been diagnosed with prediabetes or type 2 diabetes, many of the nutrition recommendations we discuss are the same things I would recommend for the general population.


Eat a variety of foods. Include vegetables and fruit. Choose higher-fibre carbohydrates more often. Get enough protein. Include healthy fats. Eat regular, balanced meals. Move your body. Enjoy foods you actually like. 


So What Actually Changes When You Have Diabetes?

There may be a little more intention behind how we put those foods together.


Because carbohydrates have the greatest direct impact on blood glucose after eating, someone living with diabetes may benefit from paying more attention to the amount, type and distribution of carbohydrate they eat throughout the day.


But paying attention to carbohydrates is very different from avoiding them.


Fruit, oats, beans, lentils, whole grains, milk, yogurt, potatoes and countless other nutritious foods contain carbohydrates. Eliminating all of these foods in the name of blood sugar control can unnecessarily restrict someone’s diet while also removing valuable sources of fibre, vitamins, minerals and enjoyment.


Instead, I often encourage people to think about the whole meal.


If you’re having toast for breakfast, what could you pair with it to add protein and staying power? Maybe eggs, Greek yogurt or peanut butter.


If you’re having rice with dinner, can we also include a good source of protein and plenty of vegetables?


If you’re having fruit as a snack, perhaps you enjoy it with some nuts, cheese or yogurt.


This is essentially the idea behind the balanced plate (one of my fav easy-to-follow guidelines): roughly half the plate vegetables, a quarter protein and a quarter carbohydrate-rich foods, with adjustments depending on the individual.


And here’s the important part: that’s not just a “diabetes plate.”


That’s a pretty reasonable way for most people to build a balanced meal.


Diabetes Nutrition Doesn’t Require Perfect Eating

Sometimes a diabetes diagnosis makes people feel as though every bite of food suddenly carries much higher stakes.


People start asking whether bananas have “too much sugar.” They stop eating potatoes. They become afraid of bread. They feel guilty if they have dessert because they believe they’ve eaten something they weren’t supposed to have.


That is not the relationship with food I’m trying to create when I provide diabetes education.


Blood glucose management is about patterns, not individual foods.


Your blood sugar is influenced by what you eat, but it’s also affected by physical activity, sleep, stress, illness, medications, hormones and many other factors. Even two people eating the exact same meal can have very different glucose responses.


That is why nutrition recommendations need to be individualized rather than reduced to a list of “good” and “bad” foods.


A glucose reading is also information, not a grade on how well you ate that day. If your blood sugar is consistently higher than your target range, that’s something worth exploring with your healthcare team. It doesn’t mean you failed.


What About Sugar?

This is usually one of the first questions that comes up, but having diabetes does not mean you can never eat sugar or dessert again.


Foods that are high in added sugars generally aren’t foods we want to make the foundation of anyone’s diet, whether they have diabetes or not. But there is a big difference between recommending that someone limit excessive amounts of added sugar and telling them they can never have a cookie again.


A piece of birthday cake is still allowed at a birthday.


Dessert can still be part of your life.


You can still eat foods simply because you enjoy them.


The goal is to look at the overall pattern of eating rather than judging someone’s health based on a single food.


And once again, that’s not particularly different from the nutrition advice I would give someone who doesn’t have diabetes.


The Basics Matter More Than The Gimmicks

Nutrition for diabetes can become unnecessarily complicated, especially online. There are supplements promising to “balance blood sugar,” extremely low-carbohydrate diets, continuous glucose monitors being marketed to people without diabetes, and endless lists of foods that supposedly “spike” glucose.


Meanwhile, the less exciting strategies continue to matter.


Eating enough fibre. Including vegetables and fruit. Choosing whole grains more often. Eating beans, lentils, nuts and seeds. Including adequate protein. Moving regularly. Getting enough sleep. Strength training. Taking prescribed medications. Not smoking. Looking after your blood pressure and cholesterol.


These aren’t flashy diabetes hacks. They’re the same foundational behaviours that support cardiovascular and metabolic health in general.


That’s especially important because diabetes management isn’t only about achieving a certain blood glucose number. It’s also about protecting long-term heart, kidney, eye, nerve and overall health.


Maybe We Should Stop Thinking About A “Diabetes Diet”

If you’ve recently been diagnosed with diabetes or prediabetes, you do not necessarily need to completely overhaul everything you eat.


Start by looking at what you’re already doing.


Maybe breakfast could use more protein. Maybe you’re going most of the day without eating and having a very large meal at night. Maybe you could add another serving of vegetables at dinner. Maybe your fibre intake is low. Maybe your carbohydrate portions could use some adjusting. Or maybe your nutrition is actually pretty solid and another part of your diabetes management plan deserves more attention.


Those are much more useful conversations than simply handing someone a list of foods they can and cannot eat.


Because ultimately, a diet that supports diabetes management looks surprisingly ordinary.


It’s balanced. It’s varied. It contains carbohydrates, protein, fats, vegetables and fruit. It makes room for enjoyable foods. It considers portions without demanding perfection. And most importantly, it needs to be something you can actually continue doing.


A healthy way of eating for someone with diabetes isn’t a special diet. It’s simply a generally well-balanced diet, individualized to the person eating it.


*An Important Note About Diabetes Medications And Insulin

While the general principles above apply broadly, diabetes nutrition is not one-size-fits-all, particularly if you take insulin or medications that can lower blood glucose.


Changes to the amount or timing of carbohydrates, skipping meals, increasing physical activity, drinking alcohol, or making significant changes to your usual eating pattern can increase the risk of hypoglycemia (low blood sugar) with certain medications or insulin. In these situations, carbohydrate intake, meal timing, medication doses and/or insulin may need to be adjusted together.


If you use insulin or a blood glucose-lowering medication, speak with your physician, pharmacist, diabetes educator or Registered Dietitian before making significant changes to your diet or activity. Your diabetes management plan should be individualized to your medications, blood glucose patterns and overall health.




Shavonne Wood, MHSc, RD, CDE

Registered Dietitian & Certified Diabetes Educator

Well Balanced RD


This article is for general education and is not a substitute for individualized medical or nutrition advice.

 
 
 

Comments


Contact

  • Instagram
  • Facebook

386 Burnham Street
Peterborough, Ontario
K9H 1T6

Phone: 705-761-6596

Fax: 705-201-5234

health@pcnm.ca

​

Free parking available

behind the building

Working Hours

MONDAY TO FRIDAY : 9AM - 5PM

Appointments available outside these hours, depending on practitioner availability.

Order supplements from our online store

Subscribe to our mailing list

© 2023 Peterborough Centre of Naturopathic Medicine

design by brandbetter

bottom of page